Final February, Denise Moore received a letter from the Oregon Division of Forestry that “instantly despatched up purple flags.” Cullen Bangs, a forest roads supervisor within the division’s Astoria district workplace, wrote that surveyors could be round her property within the weeks forward to overview boundaries between the Clatsop State Forest and close by personal property.
Moore, who has lived together with her husband and raised her three youngsters on 3 acres close to the forest for greater than 30 years, instantly emailed Bangs. She requested if the state was getting ready a timber sale close to her residence on Gnat Creek, about 20 miles east of Astoria.
Indicators mark the boundary of the Davis Ridge timber sale within the Clatsop State Forest.
Denise Moore
“The one neighbor we’ve got is ODF,” she mentioned. “Behind my thoughts I assumed, yeah, sooner or later they might do some selective harvesting.”
Bangs confirmed a timber sale would happen, however he didn’t know when. He wrote that the division would maintain Moore and neighbors apprised of the small print, timelines and processes for offering public remark.
However the letter from Bangs grew to become the primary of a number of communications, and miscommunications, between the forestry division and its Astoria workplace about two deliberate timber gross sales to involved neighbors over the course of a 12 months. The communication breakdown would ship these residents, together with neighborhood and environmental teams, right into a frenzy, finally main one timber sale to be paused indefinitely and a Board of Forestry member to resign.
The fallout over poor communication surrounding the gross sales led to an investigation by the Division of Forestry’s interim director, who has since modified the company’s coverage round contacting residents residing close to a state logging website.
Oregon’s Division of Forestry depends on timber gross sales to personal corporations in state forests for the majority of its funds wanted to handle these forests. Michael Wilson, state forests division chief on the Oregon Division of Forestry, advised the Capital Chronicle that a variety of the communication breakdown from the company comes all the way down to a scarcity of workers and a way of urgency in getting timber gross sales underway after the 2024 fireplace season delays.
“We have now been taking part in catch up since final fireplace season simply to get our core enterprise achieved in state forests,” Wilson mentioned.
Communication breakdown
The 2 proposed timber gross sales on the Clatsop State Forest close to Moore’s property — Mothball Hill and Davis Ridge — included a mixed 267 acres of clearcuts adjoining to her and others’ houses. Among the cuts could be inside 40 ft of her property, and a few neighbors had bushes proper exterior their home windows marked to be lower.
Darren Orange, whose property additionally abuts the gross sales, mentioned he didn’t hear about surveyors till Late February or early March 2024. He heard not from the state, however from Stuntzner Engineering & Forestry, a personal firm employed to do the surveying.
Like Moore’s letter, it didn’t embody any particulars about residing close to a future state timber sale, or about when the Oregon Division of Forestry would submit its draft annual operations plan that particulars which internet sites are up on the market within the 12 months forward. It additionally didn’t embody any details about how he may weigh in, although state legislation requires a 45-day remark interval for the annual plan.
Anna Kaufman and Avi Goldshmidt of the North Coast Communities for Watershed Safety measure a cedar tree inside the boundaries of the Davis Ridge timber sale.
Denise Moore
He discovered about all of that in April, a number of weeks after the plan had been posted to the forestry division’s website, when the native nonprofit conservation group North Coast Communities for Watershed Safety organized a public info marketing campaign encouraging individuals to submit feedback.
The consequence was a deluge: The forestry division acquired greater than 1,000 public feedback.
E-mail correspondence from a North Coast Communities for Watershed Safety public data request present Wilson reaching out to Chandra Ferrari, then Gov. Tina Kotek’s pure sources adviser, warning her that the governor’s workplace would most likely obtain emails from involved Astoria-area residents in regards to the gross sales, and that she ought to redirect individuals again to the forestry division.
The issue was, the forestry division was not responding to anybody, residents mentioned.
An open ear
Feeling intentionally lower off from the company after weeks of calls and emails, Moore, Orange, and members of the North Coast group, together with leaders of almost a dozen state conservation teams, expressed anger and frustration in letters and testimony on the Board of Forestry’s June 6, 2024 assembly.
New at that assembly was Bob Van Dyk, a former political science professor at Pacific College and former coverage director on the nonprofit conservation group Wild Salmon Middle, who’d been appointed by Kotek and confirmed by the Oregon Senate only a few weeks earlier. Residents emailed Van Dyk after the June board assembly to see if he, with a conservation background, would meet with them.
“My expertise with the Division of Forestry had been: For those who’re a conservationist otherwise you’re a citizen or one thing, and also you’re not a timber particular person, you’re not welcome there,” Van Dyk mentioned.
He emailed again to say he may discuss with the residents, however he cautioned them that he couldn’t affect timber gross sales as a member of the Board of Forestry. Emails reviewed by the Capital Chronicle present Van Dyk acquired permission from then-State Forester Cal Mukumoto to satisfy with residents, and that the forestry division permitted him to obtain reimbursement for mileage and an evening in an area motel, in addition to a per diem of $155 for 2 days. A 2021 legislation permits state board members to obtain a day by day allowance for official board enterprise in the event that they make underneath $50,000 yearly as a person or $100,000 yearly in a dual-income family.
Jim Kelly, the forestry board chair, mentioned that regardless of Mukumoto’s approval within the e mail, he and Mukumoto repeatedly advised Van Dyk the assembly was not a good suggestion.
“Each Cal and myself discouraged him,” Kelly mentioned. “We each reminded him that the board doesn’t have a job within the precise alternative of timber gross sales, and that it will be complicated to the general public for him to go. So we each discouraged him.”
The assembly with residents went properly, in line with Van Dyk and residents. He had invited Astoria District Forester Dan Goody to the June 24 website go to, and two different district workers got here as properly: Cullen Bangs, the district street supervisor, and Brad Catton, operations coordinator for the district.
“Till (Van Dyk) mentioned he’d come, they weren’t keen to return discuss to us,” Moore mentioned. “Then he comes and increase, we get three individuals from forestry.”
Goody advised residents on the assembly there was some flexibility to maintain buffer zones between houses and clear cuts, defend some views and to maintain among the older bushes individuals had been involved about.
“I felt good about it. I felt like these individuals received heard, you realize?” Van Dyk mentioned. “Folks nonetheless weren’t comfortable it was going to be lower, however it felt prefer it turned the temperature down a bit.”
Following the outpouring of public concern over the gross sales, however earlier than Van Dyk’s go to, officers on the Oregon Division of Forestry determined to pause transferring ahead with Mothball Hill till 2026. Officers had determined, nevertheless, that they had been going to go forward with promoting Davis Ridge to be logged in 2025.
In a July 2 letter, Goody, the district forester, wrote to close by residents that preparations for logging on the Davis Ridge website would possible start in early 2025 with a few of their enter in thoughts, and that “subject foresters will meet with adjoining landowners which have expressed the need to take action.”
Moore figured this meant Goody and others would meet together with her and neighbors earlier than any logging started. It additionally inspired them to succeed in out to company officers with any questions or issues, which they continued to do.
A closed door
Not all in Astoria had been happy with Van Dyk’s go to. After he left, Clatsop County Commissioner Courtney Bangs, sister-in-law to district street supervisor Cullen Bangs, took to Fb to criticize what she characterised as Van Dyk’s “funded” go to.
At a Sept. 4 Board of Forestry assembly, Board Chair Jim Kelly known as out Van Dyk for making the go to and requesting the per diem, saying it precipitated Kelly and Mukumoto weeks of bother and “ruined my summer season.”
Van Dyk mentioned he didn’t know the extent to which his go to had precipitated bother for Kelly and Mukumoto till that assembly. Kelly advised the Capital Chronicle that he and Van Dyk had mentioned a number of occasions the difficulty the go to had precipitated earlier than the September assembly.
Kelly publicly apologized to Van Dyk the following day in mild of issues from different board members and attendees who had been disillusioned together with his therapy of Van Dyk. A number of weeks later the board, on the request of Kotek’s pure sources adviser Geoff Huntington, employed a $250-an-hour battle mediator and advisor to analyze and to assist easy board relationships and underlying points.
The advisor, Donna Silverberg, collected almost $8,000 for her work and shared takeaways with the board, however there was no additional motion taken towards Van Dyk or Kelly.
In late October, after nearly 5 months serving, Van Dyk advised his fellow board members he wouldn’t search one other time period, feeling he not had the assist of Kelly, or the governor’s workplace that backed Kelly, and that he not wished to work with Kelly. Van Dyk’s time period formally ended originally of January.
The board has since modified its coverage to restrict what members can name official enterprise eligible for reimbursement from the state. Van Dyk’s journey to hearken to involved residents close to the 2 timber gross sales in June 2024 wouldn’t qualify underneath the brand new coverage, Kelly mentioned.
Rushed sale
In the meantime, the involved residents within the Clatsop State Forest had been caught in limbo. After that July 2, 2024 letter from Goody promising a gathering from subject foresters with adjoining landowners, Moore and others heard nothing.
However by early April 2025, they did hear the rumbling of logging roads being constructed.
They known as and emailed Goody and different district officers asking for conferences. By the April 23 Board of Forestry assembly, that they had acquired a long-awaited public data request, together with emails that confirmed Astoria foresters together with Goody gave the impression to be making an attempt to hurry the ultimate sale of the Davis Ridge logging website so it will not be delayed one other 12 months, and get one other public remark interval.
“Might you please change the public sale date for Davis Ridge to March? (…) The massive purpose we wish this sale to be auctioned in March is that it has some stress politically and we would like it to be offered previous to the general public remark interval for the FY2026 AOPs (annual operation plans),” John Tillotson, head of promoting timber gross sales within the district, emailed to an company contract specialist in January.
In one other inside e mail, Astoria District forester Goody urged promoting the Davis Ridge website in March to “save a bunch of grief throughout public remark.”
Residents and the North Coast Communities for Watershed Safety introduced these emails on the Board of Forestry’s latest April assembly, prompting board members to name for Interim State Forester Kate Skinner to analyze.
Skinner accomplished her investigation in underneath a month, and produced a three-page report, together with a timeline of communications that did or didn’t occur in an efficient approach. Company officers mentioned the Davis Ridge sale had already been permitted within the final annual operations plan and thus, by March, auctioning it off to a personal firm was not being rushed however was, actually, delayed.
Residents offered the Capital Chronicle with emails that refute Skinner’s discovering that forestry officers “didn’t obtain any contact from adjoining landowners on account of (Dan Goody’s July 2, 2024) letter.” Anna Kaufman of the North Coast Communities for Watershed Safety additionally denies Skinner’s declare within the report that Kaufman and others acquired any response from the Oregon Division of Forestry in the course of the 45-day public remark interval. She says Skinner’s declare that Astoria district foresters met together with her and different members of the group to speak in regards to the timber gross sales in January and February of 2024 is misrepresented. She mentioned she met with officers over a transparent lower close to a fish hatchery on Gnat Creek and that district foresters mentioned nothing a couple of forthcoming annual operations plan, together with the potential Mothball Hill or Davis Ridge gross sales.
Goody wrote to residents a number of weeks in the past, on April 29, to allow them to know company officers had determined to suspended the Mothball Hill sale indefinitely. Logging on Davis Ridge is underway now.
The company’s new coverage is to ship a letter to everybody residing instantly adjoining to a possible timber sale website listed within the state’s annual operations plan not less than every week earlier than the plan is printed and the general public remark interval begins, Wilson mentioned.
“We’re actually making an attempt to do higher, fairly frankly, ensuring we shut the loop on the native stage,” he mentioned.
Astoria-based state forestry officers met with Moore and neighbors in late April and once more on Might 5 to debate a plan for speaking higher with each other whereas logging work happens on the Davis Ridge website by means of October.
Moore had one thing to get off her chest, too.
“I advised them: ‘I don’t belief you anymore,’” she mentioned.
Oregon Capital Chronicle is a part of States Newsroom, a community of stories bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501(c)(3) public charity. Oregon Capital Chronicle maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Julia Shumway for questions: data@oregoncapitalchronicle.com. Observe Oregon Capital Chronicle on Fb and X.
This republished story is a part of OPB’s broader effort to make sure that everybody in our area has entry to high quality journalism that informs, entertains and enriches their lives. To study extra, go to opb.org/partnerships.
